News, sports, politics, blogs and forums for Jordan, Minnesota • (952) 492-2224

Jordan Resident's GuideLocal Worship DirectoryJordan Foreclosure Data

Jordan, Minnesota

Keep up with the Independent! Sign up for email newsletters and RSS feeds.
Click to Login
No account? Sign up!

Advertising

Advertising

Citizens use first and second public-comment periods


» Read similar stories filed under:

In response to discussion about and a decision to increase the number of public-comment periods in a Jordan City Council meeting, more than a dozen citizens turned out Monday night to talk to or watch the council in person.

One citizen warned the council that its seats would be targeted during next year's election.

Another shamed the council for apparently failing to serve the residents of Jordan.

A handful of those who attended gave opinions about the change from having one period for public comment near the beginning of each meeting to adding a second public-comment meeting near each meeting's conclusion. Mayor Pete Ewals had suggested that the public be asked to make comments during time that generally had been reserved for council discussion. 

Joshua Hein of Jordan said he expects to be heard before the council votes.

"All of you are not elected to make decisions for us. You're elected to make decisions with us," he said. "What we say should influence all your decisions."

Hein promised no shortage of candidates in the 2010 election. Seats held by Jeremy Goebel, David E. Hanson, and Jeanne Marnoff will be on the ballot. 

Carl Day of Jordan thanked the mayor for trying to allow public comment during the time at which an issue appears on the council agenda. The council instead voted 5-1 to add the second public-comment period and otherwise only allow public comment on a case-by-case basis at the consensus of the council.

"I took it as a direct insult," Day said, "not only to me but to the people of Jordan."

Advertisement. Article continues below.

Thom Boncher of Jordan offered his recollection of the early November meeting. He said one councilmember talked about teamwork. "No mention was made of how the public fits into the team," he added.

Boncher said the other councilmembers: made little or no comment; said the public treats meetings as social events; basically called the mayor a liar; wasn't there and so was off the hook; and was more concerned about disrespecting "important invited guests" than disrespecting citizens they represent.

Hanson said the second public-comment period is meant not as "simply a wrap-up of what we've discussed," which might be meaningless, but as a time when citizens can offer reflective comments, say what they didn't get to say earlier, make and bring up questions that occurred to them during the meeting. Boncher made three requests for information during the end-of-the-meeting public-comment period.

Shaw said it is largely unorthodox among cities to have public comments throughout a meeting, the format for which the mayor advocated.

"Most of them are going to offer it one time," Shaw said. "Many of them offer it only once a month."

He said he doesn't need to have the same person come to the microphone twice during the same meeting, though, just to tell the council again that she disagrees. 

"We represent all the citizens, not just the vocal ones that are at the meeting," Shaw said.




Mathias, I couldn't hear or...

Back to page top
Thom Boncher's picture

Mathias, I couldn't hear or see Ray Sandey when he spoke. Are you willing to summarize what he said?

And how on earth were you able to remember all that information about the public comments? You must have been up late putting the story together. Thanks!


Submitted by Thom Boncher on November 17, 2009 - 8:03am.

I'm a fast jotter of notes,...

Back to page top
Mathias Baden's picture

I'm a fast jotter of notes, I guess.

Sandey spoke about Fertimix, a fertilizer company that received a variance last night to build an addition.

"I would just like to publicly thank him for expanding it in Jordan," Sandey said.

(Mathias Baden is the editor of the Jordan Independent. He can be reached at editor@jordannews.com.)


Submitted by Mathias Baden on November 17, 2009 - 8:19am.

Thanks for posting a recap...

Back to page top
swansonmej's picture

Thanks for posting a recap of the meeting. I have a conflict on Monday nights so I am unable to attend. It would be great to see an agenda before the day of the meeting (at least a draft agenda) so that I can determine if something may be discussed that I would like to be present for.


Submitted by swansonmej on November 17, 2009 - 10:42am.

Swansonmej, the agenda is...

Back to page top
Thom Boncher's picture

Swansonmej, the agenda is posted on the front of City Hall the Friday before the meeting. Council members also get an information packet on Friday before the meeting. I think they have to post the agenda to comply with open meeting laws.


Submitted by Thom Boncher on November 17, 2009 - 12:25pm.

It would be great if the...

Back to page top
swansonmej's picture

It would be great if the agenda was posted online so that I
can look it over without having to drive by city hall.


Submitted by swansonmej on November 17, 2009 - 12:43pm.

Here's a correction to the...

Back to page top
Mathias Baden's picture

Here's a correction to the above story, which has been changed to reflect the right information: http://www.jordannews.com/news/city-politics/correction-2010-election-11....

(Mathias Baden is the editor of the Jordan Independent. He can be reached at editor@jordannews.com.)


Submitted by Mathias Baden on November 18, 2009 - 8:36am.

Advertising

Advertising

Recent comments

Advertising

Hot Jobs

Multi Media Sales Executive, Southwest Newspapers

Who's new

  • rs090d351
  • cbergevin
  • ScottLogan
  • gosmileseo
  • ducasLoi

Who's online

There are currently 2 users and 307 guests online.

Online users

  • Thom Boncher
  • JEAKAL

Advertising

Advertising