I have recently heard of someone from the community talking about the Marching Band's dress for the homecoming parade. I was surprised to hear that that person did not go to the teacher, but that they went to the school superinentant.
I would like to stand up for the members of the band to say that this is very displeasing. I do understand that you would like to see everyone dressed in the same thing, however you apparently are not aware of how hot the uniforms are. It is not as if the band members only were them for a little bit while they are marching. Not only do they have to wear them while they are marching and playing at the same time, but they end up actually wearing them for about an hour with driving time and time they wait before they leave the school to get to the starting of the parade/event.
I do not know if you attending the ceremony on Memorial Day at the Catholic Semetary, but the band did have two members pass out from being overheated. It was 70 degrees and breezey that day. Homecoming, this year ('08), was 86 degrees. Would you enjoy wearing a heavy polyester suit in 86 degree Minnesota humid weather? I honestly don't believe you do.
The band does wear the uniforms for the Homecoming Halftime show and the pre-game. They also wear them for Memorial Day and Heimitfest, and this year they will be wearing them for the Firefighter's *number of years* ceremony. The uniforms were bought a long time ago; they have been used enough so that the money that they cost has been overroad.
I have heard that some of the youth in the band say they will quit band for just that one reason (if they have to wear uniforms for Homecoming). Homecoming is not about being formal. Homecoming is about school pride, and as long as those kids are wearing school colors and/or band shirts, what they are wearing should be fine.


I have never seen the band...
Back to page topI have never seen the band teacher at a community event. At the Jordan Commercial Club meeting last Thursday evening during the part of the meeting when the public officials report on what is happening we received a very nice report from Kirk Nelson, superindendent, about the upcoming referendum and other items of interest happening in the school district. He also commented about homecoming and invited us to the parade, game and other activities. It was then opened to questions. I had two. The first was about the referendum and the second was "Will the band be wearing uniforms during the parade?" He assumed they would.
As far as the uniforms go, maybe each band member should have a pair of Khaki pants/shorts and a maroon polo that you can wear when it is two hot to wear the other or for different occasions. Just so they are uniform. If they all wore blue jeans and the same tshirt, they could still be uniform.
If the youth feel that not being part of the team is important, then maybe the band would be better served without them. Marching Band is a team. If the administration says "Kids, today you wear the band uniforms" then the kids should wear the band uniforms.
One of the best things about watching a marching band is the uniforms, watching the straight lines and the unified steps. When everyone is dressed the same, it just plain looks cooler.
I know that I am not the only person that feels this way and I am sure I am not the only person that said something to Mr. Nelson. As far as going directly to the teacher, no, I do not know this person. I don't have kids in the band. My access is to the administration or the school board members.
I have to ask the person who...
Back to page topI have to ask the person who submitted the last post why it's important to write that you haven't seen the band director at a community event? Are you at every community event? You also state that you don't have access to the teacher but you do to the administration and school board members. Check the school website, you can find any teacher's email address.
I understand we are all entitled to our opinions. I respect the fact that you like the uniforms being worn during the homecoming parade. Personally, it doesn't matter one way or the other to me for this particular parade. Did you see the football game Friday night? They had their uniforms on when performing.
Well I am glad they had...
Back to page topWell I am glad they had there uniforms on for the game, as they should. As far as seeing the teacher at a community event, no, I am not at every event and that wasn't what my comment was meant to say. I was at an event attended by the superintendent that offered an opportunity to ask questions related to the school. So I asked.
I am not the person that brought the question up online. There are two seperate blog posts about this topic posted on this site. They were both started by persons defending the idea of not wearing uniforms. I am just standing up and admitting that I am one person that did pose a question about the band wearing their uniform in the homecoming parade.
I have no reason to speak to the band director about this issue. I posed a question at a meeting it was Mr. Nelson's decision to use the information as he sees fit. That is his job.
At the end of the day I will not, not support the schools, the band, our local sports teams or anything else Jordan. I live in Sand Creek Township, I own a business and work in Jordan. I have lived here my whole life. My career revolves around showing families what is great about Jordan so they may choose Jordan as their home. I raise my children here. I have a vested interest in this community. Whether the band wears uniforms or not in the homecoming parade isn't going to change my feelings about Jordan. I just believe that homecoming is a time to welcome people back to the community and that putting on that uniform should be the ultimate way of showing a band members school pride.
As far as the uniforms being too warm at 70 degrees, then there is a problem. We live in Minnesota, the Marching Band marches in the spring, summer and fall and maybe in the winter when on trip to Florida. I guess we will need to look into uniforms meant for Minnesota and Florida heat. Even in an air conditioned or heated building the standard temperature is roughly 70 degrees. It may come down to conditioning. If Jordan is going to have a Marching Band maybe they need to spend time on conditioning like the sports teams do. I would guess you need to be in pretty good shape to carry some of those instruments and march.
I'm going to have to go with...
Back to page topI'm going to have to go with Ray on this one. Marching band is about appearance and attention to detail. Anybody can play an instrument. But to have 50 or 100 kids marching, in perfect sequence, playing in unison, all DRESSED ALIKE is impressive. It shows pride in yourself, pride in your school. When done well, it's truly an awesome sight.
Putting on that uniform is your job if you're in the marching band. When you put that uniform on you represent not just your school but ultimately your community and even your state. But most importantly you send a clear message to all the little kids you march past about what it means to be part of a team. You inspire them to want to be like you, for one day they'll have that job too.
You inspire thoughts such as "Wow those kids from Jordan really know their stuff. I bet their entire school is excellent." And in our case they'd be right. Our school IS extraordinary, and I'm proud to see our kids march to represent it.
Should the uniforms be updated? Sounds like maybe they should. But until they are, you're stuck with them. Whining in an online newspaper isn't going to inspire change--research alternatives and present them to the school board, as a team, in a professional manner. But jeans and T-shirts are not acceptable alternatives, no matter what your thermometer says.
One last thought to chew on--have you ever seen a Marine Corps Silent Drill Platoon? Check out this link
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y90UPLLo6nY
These men are wearing a uniform at least as hot as the JHS one. I don't hear any of them whining.
It was 86 degrees and very...
Back to page topIt was 86 degrees and very humid on Friday. Perhaps a decision was made to dress in something other than the uniforms so that the kids did not pass out from heat. How often is it 86 degrees in September? The uniforms probably work fine in cooler weather.
While it is great to see a marching band in matching outfits, it is a better call to pay attention to the weather and make sure the students are safe rather than looking alike in their uniforms.
Marching is not easy to do while playing an instrument. I wish I could have seen the band in the parade. Unfortunately, I was away at work during the day Friday.
Swansonmej, I know it's a...
Back to page topSwansonmej, I know it's a sorry substitute for actually being there, but take a look at the first part of the last video in this story: http://www.jordannews.com/news/activities/homecoming-prep-parade-8955.
(Mathias Baden is the editor of the Jordan Independent. He can be reached at editor@jordannews.com.)
Let's put the homecomming...
Back to page topLet's put the homecomming parade in perspective. It's a very casual celebration of school spirit. Should the football players all have their jerseys tucked in, have the same colored jeans on and lined up on the float in numeric order? Should the royalty be wearing their dresses and suits? How about those floats? We could put all kinds of restrictions and requirements on them! Please leave the band alone, they dressed like everyone else, in school supportive appearal. They wear their uniforms when appropriate. They had them on at the game, at Heimitfest and Memorial day. Twenty-five years ago in my "good ole days" we had a marching band that played some concerts. Now we have a concert band that marches in some parades. Is it possible to have both? I'm sure it is, but with the resources of a small high school, I'm willing to bet most usually have one or the other. Personally, I'm pleased that we have the latter. Living in Minnesota doesn't afford much marching opportunity during the school year and we have an EXCELLANT concert band. They give more concerts and have scored higher in competitions than ever. So, try a concert and see if you think a uniform for a 15 minute very casual parade is really necessary. They dress nicely for the concerts too!
I also agree with Ray. I...
Back to page topI also agree with Ray. I was in the band for many years and also had to wear band uniforms. I would have to say the uniforms of the 80's - early 90's we much heavier to wear. We wore them all the time, at 86 degrees out and at 96 degrees out. How many of the late 80's early 90's band members remember the "Hot-Humid" and were talking HOTTTT!!! State Fair parade days? Oh and by the way.....I had to also carry the Tuba. Quit complaining about the 86 degree weather, suck it up and be PROUD to be a band member. Don't get me wrong, I don't like to see kids go down because of the weather, however, I am guessing on Memorial Day, the kids that went down, probally didn't eat anything that morning and also didn't have enough liquids in them. Just like any sporting event, marching event, you have to make sure your ready to go......and and second....I can also remember wearing our uniforms for some concerts.
I have to agree with...
Back to page topI have to agree with Jason... we wore very heavy, maroon, WOOL uniforms while we marched at the State Fair, Homecoming, Memorial Day, etc. I am all for school spirit and showing off the pride by wearing school colors but there is just something about being in uniform that looks much more sharp. I know the Homecoming parade isn't exactly formal but still...
I guess the bigger 'bone' I have to pick is not so much the uniform, but the fact that the band does not march. They casually walk, more individuals out of step than in, at each parade and it's frustrating to watch. The students should be "marching", in step, with their heads held high rather than looking like it's more of a chore to be in band when you watch some of these kids go by.
I don't know what happened to the fact that the band used to begin marching band practice when the fall sports teams began their seasons as well. I know we marched at the State Fair then but we practiced every morning from 7:30 until 8:45 and then went to our respective sports practices. It seems as though more pride needs to be taken in our band... from every aspect!
You said you don't see a...
Back to page topYou said you don't see a need to talk to our director about this "problem," but the director is the one you should talk to. If you would have a problem with how a sport team is dressed, you would talk to their coach. Our director is our coach.
You also do not understand that our director did not go to school to be a teacher. He was in music proformance in college, which meant he just wanted to play in different bands, which is what he did.
He absolutly dislikes marching band, that is why we don't march with our knees high, but that is not why we do not dress in uniforms for Homecoming.
We have suggested to him that we get matching shirts and pants instead of the heavy uniforms. Many other schools do that, and it is a lot more up witht the times.
We always wear our uniforms for the Homecoming game; we always have; we just don't for the parade. It is a lot of work to get into the uniforms, and we end up being in the uniform for like an hour or more when we march in them.
Yes, you might have had to do the same thing when you were in band, and yes, your uniforms might have been heavier, but that doesn't mean it has to be that way for us. You know how bad it was to dress in them. Just because ten years ago the seventh graders got shoved into lockers, doesn't mean it has to happen every year for ever. Times change and fads go.
Yes, we should have these heavy uniforms, but they should be worn only at the formal events like Memorial Day and Heimitfest (as we do and have done), but for days when it is about showing school spirit, as the Homecoming Parade is, we should get to wear our school colors or our Pep Band shirts, which we have, and is what we did.
We don't practice like sports do with marching because our director does not like marching band and does not put much time into it. Also, our band is not big enough to have a corriographed field show. We are too small, and as I and my brother and sister remember, they tried to do a complex corriographed field show for Homecoming a while ago and it just looked not a jumble of nothing.
And I agree with DMRSandCreek. We do very well at during band contest, we received the highest rating at our contest last year; the year before that we received a very high rating. We challange ourselves with Catagory 1 music with just about every piece we play. You can come to one of our concerts and tell us we are not the best band around, we will all be very surprised.
Bucky, I disagree with you. Not anyone can play an instrument. Not everyone has the discipline to learn an instrument. Not everyone can march and play at the same time. It takes time, skill, and practice.
Ray, we always have uniforms on for the Homecoming game. If you came to more homecoming games, you would have known this. The fact that our band director might not go to events is not up to the people in band. He is a very busy man that can't just drop everything to go to a community event. The administration should and does not tell us when and when not to wear uniforms. As far as you saying, you don't know the director means nothing. Just because you don't know him does not mean you can not talk to him. Just because you don't know a person doesn't mean you don't ask them directions. Just because you don't know a cashier at the grocery store, does not mean you do not say hello to them or answer their questions. Our director is a nice man who would have listened to you if you had took the time to walk the twenty more feet to talk to him rather than talking to the superintendant.
Honestly, I (representing myself; not the rest of the band or school) don't believe you should be offended because we don't wear our uniforms for Homecoming. Homecoming is not about Jordan as a town. Homecoming is about High School sports, and that is what we are supporting. We were very festive in our school colors. If you are offended by that, why are you not offended by the school not requiring school uniforms every school day or requiring every clothing company to make the same color shirts and pants, that way everyone can look the same all the time. Shouldn't you have the wear the same color shirt as your co-workers at work so you represent your company well and respectivly? This is what you are saying about our band. I should go to your place of employment and tell your boss that I am offended that everyone is wearing different things, that they don't look the exact same and aren't in step with everyone else.
The world is not a perfect place and just because you have a problem with something doesn't mean you should have the right to dictate over things that are going on. We have been marching without uniforms for the Homecoming parade for years, why would we change that now?
(I do not mean to sound mean, but it sounds like it would be that way.)
Those of you who wore the...
Back to page topThose of you who wore the heavy wool uniforms, did you walk to and from school two miles uphill both ways too? Seriously though, I think it's great people have pride in something that they used to do years ago. So I can see your point. But I have to agree with a lot of the points made by the last poster (composition.notebook).
back in the day when we used...
Back to page topback in the day when we used to walk up hill both ways and carried the tuba players on our backs in the rain.... There was occasion to break from the full uniform, not too often. The full wool uniforms were prior to my date, we had the vapor trapping Polyester. Since then the band has undergone cutbacks and many things now have to be picked up by the parents of the band members. The band has also reduced in members as years ago the band was larger with a smaller school size. Instruments are not cheap and even the amount of time delegated to practice has been reduced. I was at the parade and not offended, I was at the game and also not offended. They are a High School Band, I am sure they can improve. They are also kids and I hope that at times they can have some fun. Lighten up, The Game was Good "Go Hubmen".
I still don't believe...
Back to page topI still don't believe Homecoming is a community event. Yes the community is there, but it is not as formal and big as Memorial Day or Heimitfest. We do wear uniforms for those. It always is hot on the day of Homecoming, and if you like it or not, some people don't do well in heat. We know better than to not eat breakfast or be dehydrated before marching.
Dan, you likely did not do that. Band teachers won't let kids go outside in the rain, because the instruments will rust and get all gross. I am pleased to hear that you were not offended by our not wearing uniforms at the parade; it means a lot that our possible Future-Mayor is on the side of the kids in band and that you are concerned about the health and well-being of this towns youth. :)
Composition.Notebook I...
Back to page topComposition.Notebook I agreed with almost everything you said before, but I have to say that Homecoming is a community event in smaller communities like ours.
Homecoming is about...
Back to page topHomecoming is about community... granted it is celebrated more by the high school students, but it's about the community/alumni coming back home. In a small town like Jordan many things are community related whether we like them to be or not.
I don't think that any one of us that have blogged would want to see any kids pass out from heat with the uniforms and we're not trying to be all 'back when I was young'... what we are saying is that it has been done, it is still done by many bands and it is possible. This isn't a personal attack on the youth, it's a voicing of opinions on the fact that the band, and the pride that used to radiate from it, have somewhat disappeared.
I don't know if the JHS band...
Back to page topI don't know if the JHS band has done this, since I haven't seen them march since I was in school, but on hot parade days I see people walking with marching bands with water bottles and towels to hydrate band members during the parade. Maybe the band could round up some volunteer parents to help with that if it isn't done already...?
And it irks me to hear that the current band director doesn't like marching and doesn't require marching at parades. (said Composition.Notebook)
We used to have someone that...
Back to page topWe used to have someone that brought bottles of water for us and was waiting for us at the end of the parade so we could drink something right after.
With the heat of the day combined with the heat of the formal uniforms, I don't believe it is practical for most of the events we are at to wear the formal uniforms. We could get like a cardigan or something that is not hot that could just cover up a undershirt because normally when we march it is hot, or semi-hot. I am not apposed to that idea. However, I am still not persuaded to wear any kind of uniform for the event of Homecoming. People like the football players that are in band enjoy football and would like to show that they are in the sport, because they can't be on the football float because band is a school activity while football is not.
I was in Band and I was in...
Back to page topI was in Band and I was in Football. Just before homecoming my senior year some parents and an unnamed problem teacher, who later made the news, pressured the high school to rethink their policies. I had to make a decision to pull out of band or football. I chose to stay in football. It should not be assumed that outside pressures do not adversely affect the band and some of the kids in the band. The style that is now used by the band is from the drum and bugle core. The style Cliff taught us was the military march. I was also in the James Gang Drum and Bugle Core. I prefer the look of the military march myself, however being in both have found the core style to be less painful and the uniforms less cumbersome as well as less expensive. The core style is now used more than the military march as it allows for more stylized movements and even can affect the music. Yes, Cliff was a great director and one of the last to hold out for the military march. The Band was more celebrated and more students were willing to participate in band. I would love to see Jordan attain the same level of music and members that we had in the past. I would also like to see the community behind them as they were in the past. If the current director needs constructive criticism it should be given and appreciated with out breaking the spirit of the kids or turning into an insult match. I have a niece in the band and to me it appeared that they were expressing team spirit; however it is the director that sets the doctrine the students abide to. I would bet that next year they are in full uniform and some of the students will be disappointed. As for pride they learn that from their parents and how their parents take pride in school, community, state and nation… are your flags flying? I know that many are not. My flag flies for the kids, parents, uncles and friends who have given or may be asked to give their life for their country. I still have my letterman’s jacket and am attempting to install a sense of pride in my children, so as the Beach Boys sang… “Be true to your School”. As Crosby, Stills and Nash sang… “Teach your children well”.
Sounds like we need to start...
Back to page topSounds like we need to start up the Alumni Band again....Can I borrow a Tuba?
Here here!! :) With all...
Back to page topHere here!! :)
With all due respect I was also in drum corps and we "marched"... these kids do not even resemble marching, they aren't remotely in step, and that falls on the director. I agree with Andy that it's disappointing to hear that the band director doesn't like marching... it's part of the job sorry.
One last thing, Composition.notebook, you mentioned that you had parents that would be waiting for you after parades... don't you have any parents that actually march along side of you with water bottles in hand to give you drinks while marching? Just wondering because we had parents that were always willing to do that so that none of the students would unfortunately pass out. We also marched more often than you guys do,at the State Fair, Disney World, Epcot... it's a real bummer the band director doesn't like marching. We were fortunate enough to go to Florida every three years to march and those were some awesome parades and memories!
We had a parent waiting at...
Back to page topWe had a parent waiting at the end, than that kid quit band. I honestly do not believe our director would allow parents with water marching with us because it just won't look professional., but I could be wrong.
Besides that, the uniforms are still out of date. From what I have seen with other local bands that march in parades in their town, they wear band shirts and black shorts (yes, this is a nearby town). I've seen a number of school bands do that. We recently went to Florida, this last spring break. The kids had fun there, but they didn't march, they just had a concert. This has recently been added because now the school trusts the music teachers (for they have not been with us long and the teachers thought we should have a trip that both band and choir went to). I don't believe the State Fair will be added into our marching because it costs too much money to drive there and it is not during the school year, and many kids would not be able to practice or get up the the school every day to practice for it. Not to say, we are lazy, just saying we have other things, like jobs or little brothers/sisters to watch. Also, fund raising for that kind of thing is hard to get started and the school does a lot of fund raising as it is. As for parents paying for it, many parents are in debt as it is (with our failing economy) and we don't want to put more pressure on them.Our music funding has been cut down a lot. We have been playing the same songs for pep band that they had before we got there. We have one new pep band song this year, and from my knowledge that's the only new pep band song we have gotten within the last four or five years. I also don't believe we have enough to buy new music for concerts either. But that could be wrong. I am not the accountant.
Buzz Band forever!!! I agree...
Back to page topBuzz Band forever!!!
I agree with Jason, let's get the alumni buzz band together! Not to take anything away from the JHS band. I give these kids credit for sticking it out with band. With all of the class requirements that have been forced on these kids and less time for electives, those in band are giving up the opportunity to take classes in home ec (FACS now - remember foods and clothing?), industrial arts (do they still call it that?), computers, business, art, etc. Things are different now, and we are fortunate to still be able to offer fine arts opportunities. Who knows what the future will hold with budget cuts.
Those sound like...
Back to page topThose sound like assumptions by Composition.Notebook.
My thoughts on a couple things:
Parents walking with band with water bottles look unprofessional? I guess not marching in sync IS professional? The director's standards, as you have stated them, are pretty messed up if he thinks helping parents is a bad look for the band.
Not being able to practice outside of the school schedule because kids are busy? Ummm... what about the kids that are in sports? It is a school activity. Just like sports, if you want to be good at it, you have to practice. Even outside of school hours. Band members should want to get out to show other cities, especially at the State Fair, how good Jordan is.
And fundraising can always be done, but I know how much it can suck. But it can be done.
I wasn't in band, but I look at it the same as sports.
Comp....you say other towns...
Back to page topComp....you say other towns wear t-shirts.....have you been to a State Fair parade, every town there Big and Small are wearing the traditional Band Uniform. I have to say this, its all the Band Director. I know numberous kids that have quit the band over the past 3-4 years and they all state the same reason.
and since were talking band....Where the heck were ya for the Homecoming volleyball match? I would have figured thats one match you would have forsure played for. Did any members of the band bring up why you were not playing?
Not to bring up the Buzz Band again, however there were a few times that our "famous" director could not make a game, it that case we usually had a drummer lead the band, sounded still awesome.
Band is a CLASS, not an...
Back to page topBand is a CLASS, not an extra-curricular activity. It is a Concert band class, not marching band, not pep-band, and certainly not a sport!
The reason the band didn't go to the volleyball homecoming game, is because of parents' complaints. They don't want the students going to more than one game a week,and they don't want them to stay the entire game. The reason being, again, because it is a class. You didn't have to take a foods class, and have to bake for all the volleyball, football, and basketball games, AND community events did you?
And the band must support all of Jordan, but few of Jordan can support the band? How many of you have been to a band concert? You know, the event that they play all the music they've practiced EVERY day at. And if you do happen to go please don't complain they're not wearing their uniforms, because the international concert wear is black and white.
Have you looked back on your comments? All of you telling us how "bad" we are? The state judges must not know anything about music, if they give us so many awards. We were half-stepping the entire homecoming parade, because the police "escort" in front of us was going too slow, thus attributing to us being out of step. And The freshman members of our band had just learned to march that week!
And PLEASE, lay off our director. How many of you know him? Let he who has the time to do his job throw the first stone. He deserves ALL the respect you could possibly give him. I give him all of my respect! He was hired for and teaches CONCERT band. That's what he went to school for, but he still likes pep band and marching. That's just not his forte, so please excuse him. If the band still displeases you than feel free to get a "real" band, but don't forget to pay them "real" money.
All of you say you support anything Jordan, but I guess that somehow excludes the JORDAN band, because there sure is a lot of critisizm going around! What ever happened to praising children, rather than insulting, when they make a perfectly good effort!
The only thing I'll comment...
Back to page topThe only thing I'll comment on is the discrepancy between "J-townfanmischief" and "Composition.Notebook"'s comments...
Earlier Composition.Notebook said, "He (the band director) absolutly dislikes marching band, that is why we don't march with our knees high..."
Now J-townmischief says, "he (the band director) still likes pep band and marching. That's just not his forte..."
Both of you are spouting off things like they are facts. One, or both, of you are wrong. So at this point it's hard to believe anything you two comment on.
All of my comments are my opinion, so take them as they are.
And I still think band is more extra-curricular than just a class.
My original comment was that...
Back to page topMy original comment was that the "Marching Band" should wear Band Uniforms while marching in the homecoming parade. I was told to keep my nose out of it because it wasn't about me. I wasn't going to speak to or about the band director because I don't know him. I had access to the superintendant so I said something to him.
Also if you look back at the beginning of the threads on this subject, you brought it up, we didn't.
Wow. All I can say is be...
Back to page topWow. All I can say is be glad the band has only had ONE director for awhile. And I use the word "awhile" loosely. I joined JHS band as soon as Mr. Klehr offered lessons (5th or 6th grade) During my entire school career in Jordan (K-12) we had FOUR count them, FOUR band directors. Cliff Klehr first, then retired. Ms. Heidi Thelan (I think, its been awhile), second, replaced due to "accusations." Third, Mr. Webber, resigned. Fourth, my senior year, can't remember her name though....Miss something or other...
My point, at least this guy seems to care about the band in some aspect. Whether or not he likes marching band, I know the band does well in concert settings, and that says something. I personally feel that I didn't get that much out of band during the 6-7 years I was a member due to the incredible turnover in directors. Each director was so different in personality, musical tastes, etc. there was never any consistancy. Band trip to Florida? HA. NEVER happened. Oh, and the uniforms in discussion, we were fitted for those going into the 9th grade (class of 2001) I remember it was such a HUGE deal, because they were so "top of the line" and expensive. We had to take incredible care of those uniforms, that sadly, we barely ever wore due to the complete chaos caused by high turnover in directors.
It was great being able to wear those brand new custom fit uniforms with pride----when it wasn't too hot or humid.
In my opinion, a quality director is more important than "nice, community pride inspiring" uniforms. Both would be great, but can't we be happy that we at least have the important part covered?
I have been to many band...
Back to page topI have been to many band concerts and have never said I don't like listening to the band playing. We too had "CONCERT" band in school, that usually started in the winter months, and yes we won many awards and competitions also. I guess I would have a problem with the "parents" then. Seems like they don't want you playing those expensive instruments they have bought you more than once a week, seems like they don't want to march along the side and carry water for you during a hot parade, seems like they just want to sit back in the audatorium and watch a concert band play. Things have really changed.
I hope the band continues to do good at State competitions, and also continue the good concert band music.
Yeah. Our Concert Band goes...
Back to page topYeah. Our Concert Band goes all year; it's been that way for years. I agree that many of you seem to not appreciate the Jordan Band. We are tiny (approximately half of what my parents had when they were in band) and the fact that we are as good and powerful as we are is incredible. Our director, honestly, like I said before, does not like marching. I remember him telling us this a few years ago. Just because he doesn't like it, doesn't mean he doesn't try to get us up to a decent standard. And the fact is that the only practicing we did in the week of the homecoming parade is the practicing we did on the field for the field show. The cop was driving very slow, and marching in step at a slow pace while playing a faster song is incredibly hard. I understand that seeing a band out of step looks horrible, but that is how it went. And the people that hold the flag do not count, we honestly pulled them out of class that morning and asked them to hold our flag (same as we did for Hemitfest). Parents have changed over years, yes. Parents don't want to have to drive their children up to the school five times a week to play for pep band (at volleyball games and such), because I'm sure many of them were not in band and do not want to "waste" gas. And it is a relatively short amount of time we play, lasting about an hour for Volleyball.
Homecoming is the one parade, the one time throughout the entire year, we don't wear uniforms when we possibly could. Don't get so bent out of shape for one time. Jordan is our home, and we feel comfortable enough that we believe that the community will see that Homecoming is more of a high school dress up event than a big community event. Yes, it is about people coming back, but we have not dressed in formal uniforms for the Homecoming Parade for years.
All of you are saying formal, hot, polyester uniforms could be worn and that many schools wear them. But just because everyone does it, doesn't mean it is good. So if someone jumps off a bridge, I guess "all" of you would too.
Jason - Have you noticed that we do not play the State Fair? If we played the State Fair, I'm sure we would wear uniforms, but we don't play at that.
I'm glad the alumni posting...
Back to page topI'm glad the alumni posting on this forum have good memories of their days in band. I'm glad they had an excellent MARCHING band, back in the day.
Today, in 2008, the fact is, Jordan's band program is different from "back in the day." Different director, different kids, different amount of adminstrative support, different funding, and a different musical focus. (And from the looks of this forum, a different amount of community support as well.) Nobody can reasonably expect the exact same appearance from an entirely different program. Times change.
In 2008, we have a CONCERT band that takes the highest level awards in comptetition. We have a director that works hard and demands a lot from his students to make that happen. The fact that marching band is not top priority at JHS in 2008 is just how it is.
I think we would benefit from valuing what is here in the present rather than nit-picking and making comparisions to the past. Let's live in the present.
Matthias--your edit of my...
Back to page topMatthias--your edit of my post on this topic which appeared in the print edition misrepresented my intent. My point was that in 2008, we have an excellent, award winning CONCERT band, and alumni should be aware of that fact and apprieciate the program for those accomplishments. Unfortunately, your edit of my words (which were intended only as a lead in to my point) could easily be read to express the "It ain't what it used to be" sentiment I was tactfully trying to discourage.
I feel you used my words out of context, which I think might be taboo in journalism, am I correct? I guess I'll post more succinctly in the future, so as to reduce the risk of being edited for content again.
Yea, Rah Rah Band!
Jtownmomof3, I can...
Back to page topJtownmomof3, I can understand your concern and I appreciate you letting me know. I thought your words were tactful, and that is why I quoted you in the print edition.
Yes, things are always out of context in the newspaper and on this Web site. Truth is told over a long period of time, through a number of stories, comments, letters to the editor, columns, blogs, and various other things that newspaper people and readers do.
In this case, by putting part of the online conversations in the print edition, I was trying to provide a snapshot for readers. Some others might want to join in the conversation.
As a side note, writers: Please note that content appearing on this Web site, even if it is submitted by a reader, is the property of Southwest Newspapers. Thank you for writing.
(Mathias Baden is the editor of the Jordan Independent. He can be reached at editor@jordannews.com.)
I have asked the director...
Back to page topI have asked the director why we don't play at the State Fair anymore? He has never once said it's cause he don't like to march, he told me it was hard to get the kids to show up for practice for it. If he don't like to march, I would have loved to heard that from him and would have accepted that answer.
I think the band does a...
Back to page topI think the band does a fantastic job for a small size band, they sound amazing. I'm always so proud of them at the Volleyball games and Football games or anything they're performing at. If you think about it, it's a very big commitment. So far this year they've played at 4 Football games, 2 Volleyball games, Homecoming Corination, Heimitfest Parade and the Homecoming Parade and it's just the beginning of October. The run to the Volleyball State Tournament is just around the corner and the Band in the past has performed at every game starting with Section play. That can mean up to 2 games a week. Right after that it's Basketball season. Being the size that they are, the kids are all required to show up for all these functions. State Fair-not a priority.
Being an alumni myself of...
Back to page topBeing an alumni myself of "Buzz's Band" ('84-'87), State Fair was a priority, in addition to Homecoming, the football, volleyball, basketball games and wrestling matches (providing pregame/match and half-time music).
After the fall sports season, we started practice for the winter and spring concerts, but still provided the music for the winter sports. During the spring, we got back in shape for the Memorial Day ceremonies.
Yes, the maroon wool uniforms were hot, but as mentioned above, it was something that we had to condition ourselves for. And just like athletes have to condition for their respective sports, band members also have to condition themselves for whatever parades that are done. I also was on two Florida trips, and we marched Disneyworld, Seaworld, Old Town, as well as performances at EPCOT. All done in the maroon wool uniforms - talk about hot and sticky...
If there's a legitimate problem with the white poly uniforms and heat, then maybe the school should look into newer, lightweight fabrics that still look professional for both parades and concerts.
I'd love to be part of the alumni band; unfortunately my current job situation has me out of state (and soon to be country)!
I agree with Skruger. I know...
Back to page topI agree with Skruger. I know they have gone to many of the events the band has played at, for I have seem them there taking photos. I appreciate that.
JeffyB, just because you were put through the misery of wearing the hot band uniforms, doesn't mean it needs to stay that way. Times do chance, and if you believe in global warming, you would understand that the world is warmer than it was twenty years ago when you wore them. I agree that the school needs to take steps to make sure the kids who have to wear them are safe and will not pass out wearing the uniforms when they march. They should get uniforms that are not as hot, but they do not have any money in the budget to buy new uniforms. This is why just wearing school colors on Homecoming is a good way to go. It is comfortable, and it is a lot less hot than the uniforms are.
CN, I understand that it...
Back to page topCN,
I understand that it doesn't need to be that way, hence the reason for stating that if there is an actual need, the school needs to look into lighterweight uniforms that still look professional.
We did have some folks fall out during one of the trips to Florida, but again, it comes down to conditioning.
I don't have any problem in wearing matching pants and shirts, and if it means tan khakis, and maroon or white polos with an embroidered band logo and matching tennis shoes (all white) for comfort when the temps are going to be above 75, then I'm all for it, as long as there's uniformity amongst the band members.
I've seen other school's marching bands at State Fair in recent years wear Dockers and polos and they still look sharp when they march.
If you watched the...
Back to page topIf you watched the Oklahoma/Texas game on Saturday, you may have noticed that they showed a clip of the band marching in the parade before the game and they were all wearing T-shirts and shorts. Now, they were all the same color but they were the school colors. Then, during the game, they were wearing their marching uniforms. Personally, I don't have a problem with them not wearing their uniforms for the homecoming parade. It's more about school spirit and pride than show.
Yup. That's what I'm getting...
Back to page topYup. That's what I'm getting at. Many of the kids are talking about doing something like that.