Motorbuys | Local Jobs | Homes | Rental Property | Coupons | Garage Sales| Classifieds | Worship | ShopNow
July 5, 2008, 3:43 pm
Send your favorite photo to  snapshots at Jordan Independent

Advertising

Welcome to the new Jordannews.com, the home page of the Jordan Independent newspaper. Let us know what you think of the changes to the site.
Got a news tip? Email us, or call us at (952) 492-2224

User login

Email Edition
Type in your email address and click "Subscribe" to receive our E-mail Edition in your inbox.




Add our RSS feed to your favorite service.

Add to Google Reader or Homepage

Subscribe in NewsGator Online

Add to My AOL

Get Firefox

Real life vs. Hollywood

Filed under:


No votes yet

Have you ever watched a movie or TV show that supposedly shows your job and think to yourself, “Yeah, right!”?  (While I’m not a teacher, as the son of two teachers I watched NBC’s “Teachers” last year and thought about how ridiculous it was.)

For some reason I was thinking about movies and jobs today. There are quite a few movies that show journalists at work – some are good, some are bad, and some are good movies despite bad depictions of what it means to be a reporter. I started wondering which movie about my job is the best.

After talking with Editor Mathias Baden, I’m even less sure. While I really like “Almost Famous,” it isn’t really all that much about journalism. I’d say that “All the President’s Men” – about the Nixon Watergate scandal – is one of the better movies out there, but really just for a few scenes that show the reporters’ (Woodward and Bernstein) excitement over following a lead and finding new information.

I’ve also heard that “Office Space” is spot-on in its depiction of corporate jobs, and that “Law and Order” is a pretty accurate depiction of working in the legal system. Of course there are also jobs that never get much publicity. For all the cop, doctor, and lawyer shoes out there, there aren’t many shows and movies about small businesses, banks, or public employees.

What are the TV shows or movies that you think best represent your job? Or is your job underrepresented in Hollywood?


Thorachotomy tray in E.R. I...

Back to page top

Thorachotomy tray in E.R.

I was a big fan of the television show E.R. for several years, and noticed that every other episode had an Intern asking for a Thorachotomy (chest cracking) tray.

On a flight back from Chicago once, I spoke with a Doctor who did his Internship at HCMC, the Minneapolis Equivalent of the hospital in the show. I asked him how may times in his 4 years that he actually cracked someones chest, and he said he had NEVER done it. If someone required open heart surgery, they would be moved to surgery where a Cardiologist would perform the procedure.

That's Hollywood for ya!


Submitted by Robert Envall on September 20, 2007 - 2:34pm.

Doctor shows, and most cop...

Back to page top
Brandon's picture

Doctor shows, and most cop shows are so ridiculously over the top. I think my favorite unbelievable show has got to be “CSI.” I mean, how many absurd crimes have they solved in a few short years? And “24” also routinely stretches the bounds of believability.


Submitted by Brandon on September 20, 2007 - 2:47pm.

Yeah, they should do more...

Back to page top
Mathias Baden's picture

Yeah, they should do more shows about petty theft, domestic "situations" that gets resolved with a quick police call, noise complaints, water-ordinance violations, and gas drive-offs. Boring stuff to get kids to turn off the tube once a week.

(Mathias Baden is the editor of the Jordan Independent. He can be reached at editor@jordannews.com.)


Submitted by Mathias Baden on September 20, 2007 - 3:36pm.

As a journalist, I agree...

Back to page top

As a journalist, I agree "Almost Famous" is a great movie, but not about journalism. One of my favorite flicks about journalism is "All the Presidents Men."

But here is another one you should check out if you haven't seen it, "The Paper." I thought they did a fairly good job depicting the trade.

Another great journalism movie is "Shattered Glass." It is about Stephen Glass, a great writer, but a fraud of a journalist who used to write for The New Republic.


Submitted by shawn hogendorf on September 20, 2007 - 3:25pm.

Advertising

Advertising

Our Other Sites

Newspapers

The Chaska Herald
News, community information, and an online gathering place for residents of Chaska, Minnesota.
The Chanhassen Villager
News, community information, and an online gathering place for residents of Chanhassen, Minnesota.
The Eden Prairie News
News, community information, and an online gathering place for residents of Eden Prairie, Minnesota.
The Shakopee Valley News
News, community information, and an online gathering place for residents of Shakopee, Minnesota.
The Jordan Independent
News, community information, and an online gathering place for residents of Jordan, Minnesota.
The Prior Lake American
News, community information, and an online gathering place for residents of Prior Lake, Minnesota.
The Savage Pacer
News, community information, and an online gathering place for residents of Savage, Minnesota.
Victoria Town Square.com
News, community information, and an online gathering place for residents of Victoria, Minnesota.
Minnesota Reader.com
Links to news and community information gathered from dozens of Minnesota newspapers, open for comments, discussion and rating by readers.

Entertainment

Let's Go! Southwest
Arts, entertainment and "to do" information for the Minnepolis southwest suburbs includes extensive events calendar.

Churches

Worship Directory
Churches and worship services in the southwest suburbs of Minneapolis and St. Paul, including the cities of Chaska, Chanhassen, Eden Prairie, Jordan, Savage, Shakopee, and Prior Lake.

Community Guides

Guide to Belle Plaine
Community guide highlights important people, places and events in Belle Plaine, Minnesota.
Guide to Carver and Cologne
Community guide highlights important people, places and events in Carver and Cologne, Minnesota.
Guide to Chanhassen
Community guide highlights important people, places and events in Chanhassen, Minnesota.
Guide to Chaska
Community guide highlights important people, places and events in Chaska, Minnesota.
Guide to Eden Prairie
Community guide highlights important people, places and events in Eden Prairie, Minnesota.
Guide to Excelsior
Community guide highlights important people, places and events in Excelsior, Minnesota.
Guide to Jordan
Community guide highlights important people, places and events in Jordan, Minnesota.
Guide to Prior Lake
Community guide highlights important people, places and events in Prior Lake, Minnesota.
Guide to Savage
Community guide highlights important people, places and events in Savage, Minnesota.
Guide to Shakopee
Community guide highlights important people, places and events in Shakopee, Minnesota.
Guide to Victoria
Community guide highlights important people, places and events in Victoria, Minnesota.

Classifieds

Southwest Jobs Now
Job listings and career opportunities in the southwest suburbs of Minneapolis and St. Paul, including the cities of Chaska, Chanhassen, Eden Prairie, Jordan, Savage, Shakopee, and Prior Lake.
Southwest Homes Now
Real estate listings and homes for sale in the southwest suburbs of Minneapolis and St. Paul, including the cities of Chaska, Chanhassen, Eden Prairie, Jordan, Savage, Shakopee, and Prior Lake.
Southwest Shop Now
Job listings, used items, garage sales, and everything you'd find in the classifieds. Items from the southwest suburbs of Minneapolis and St. Paul, including the cities of Chaska, Chanhassen, Eden Prairie, Jordan, Savage, Shakopee, and Prior Lake.
Motorbuys.com
Shop online for a great selection of vehicles from Central Minnesota and the Southwest Metro Area.

Coupons

SaverFreak, Minnesota's once-a-week super coupon deal.
Southwest Coupons Online
Printable coupons for deals and discounts from stores and service shops in the southwest suburbs of Minneapolis and St. Paul, including the cities of Chaska, Chanhassen, Eden Prairie, Jordan, Savage, Shakopee, and Prior Lake.